Violence We can no longer assume that
we live in a pristine safe corner of the world insulated from wars, conflicts,
animosities and contentiousness - if we did assume that.
One of my most vivid memories of living
in Marietta in the 1950's was seeing the girls (invariably white) wearing
poodle skirts puffed out with crinoline, seeing the boys with blue jeans
with cuffs turned up (they were invariably Protestant), hearing a preacher
uncle badgering us kids around the annual Christmas tree with harangues
against Catholics, Blacks and Jews before we could open presents and somehow
feeling that the threat was from without -NAACP, ACLU, the federal government
and in particular, Yankees. There was somewhat of a siege mentality
but were we really that safe from within?
As time went on I learned that I had
more than one relative who was KKK, White Citizens Council or White Supremacist
or such - I also learned of violent drunken fights, and massive denial
and minimizing of what I would now call family violence. I had more than
one relative who had witnessed lynchings. Oh to be Southern and a hypocrite
- Violence amidst the magnolias.
What to make of this drama? Was
it unique? I doubt it. Was it socially accepted - in some circles.
Was it confusing? You bet. Was it spiritual? NO! Was
it right ? Absolutely not. The same ministers who railed
against integration now rail against gays and lesbians -all the while wrapping
themselves in some bizarre interpretation of some sentence taken out of
context from the Old Testament.
Is it true that good literature demands conflict
? Is it true that people only pay attention to the news if there is blood
and gore? Do we have to have fist fights, wars and drubbing ? Are we doomed
to some sort of instinct of aggression? Freud thought so and referred to
life and death instincts.
According to the American Psychological Association
if you see these signs, violence is a serious possibility:
Loss of temper
Frequent physical fighting
Significant vandalism or property damage
Increase in use of drugs or alcohol
Increase in risk taking behavior
Detailed plans to commit acts of violence
Announcing threats or plans for hurting
others
Enjoying hurting animals
Carrying a weapon
Gang Membership
Access to or fascination with weapons,
especially guns
Threatening others regularly
Trouble controlling feelings like anger
Withdrawal from friends and usual activities
Feeling rejected and alone
Having been the victim of bullying
Poor school or work performance
History of discipline problems
Failing to acknowledge the feelings
or rights of others
Feeling constantly disrespected
What might we do to control, prevent and treat
violence ~
1st: do not assume someone else
will deal with the situation - denial and minimization are powerful defense
mechanisms.
2nd: be safe - do not spend time alone
with people showing warning signs.
3rd: if possible remove the person from
the situation that is triggering the violent behavior.
4th: tell somebody.
5th: get protection if need be.
6th: ask professional for help - do no go
it alone.
The American Psychological Association
states that violence is the act of purposely hurting someone. I suppose
that such can happen at home, community, school and work - then we can
conceptualize family violence, community violence, school violence and
workplace violence. The usual forms of such hurt are physical, sexual and/or
psychological - and the worst of the three may well be psychological.
We, as human beings, have a long history of
violence. Even some of our religions have been violent - witness the Crusades
of the medieval times, the warlike lyrics of Onward Christian Soldiers
and references to martyrs, the use of the cross at KKK rallies, and almost
an expectation that to be religious would invite persecution and vilification.
A dominant goal of evangelical Christians is to make the world Christian
- is it surprising that the rise of the Christian Coalition, Focus on the
Family, American Family Association and such make us all nervous ? For,
my bet is, if the religious political extremists with their incessant drumbeat
of antigay, antiabortion, anti sex education, antipublic school, anti gun
control, anti arts rhetoric ever gained political control we would have
a society very close to that seen in The Handmaid's Tale where to question
was to be punished and where violence in the name of religion was lust
fine.
What causes violence? Let me count the ways.
Remember Cain and Abel ? Remember the Flood? Remember the story of Jesus
cursing the fig tree or throwing the money changers out of the Temple?
How about David and Goliath or the U.S. Civil War in which ten times more
American casualties were inflicted than in Viet Nam, or World War I - The
War to End All Wars - only to be upstaged by World War II when seven million
Jews, twenty million Russians and millions more around the world died.
The sheer brutality of war, serial killings
and mass murders seems to have escalated. Maybe the increasing presence
of guns means one deranged killer can do away with many others instead
of few others where there is no gun.
Factors that contribute to violent behavior
include peer pressure, need for attention and respect, feelings of low
self worth, early childhood abuse or neglect, witnessing violence at home,
in the community or in the media and easy access to weapons.
Yale researchers years ago developed a frustration/aggression
hypothesis of aggression. The notion was that the inability to attain something
heightened the impulse to lash out.
Some people use violence to release feelings
of anger or frustration. Others use violence as a way to control others
or get something they want.
Violence is used to retaliate against those
who have hurt them or someone they care about.
Violence is learned behavior and can be modeled
from others.
School violence has become monotonously frequent
with shootings in Mississippi, Oregon, Georgia, Colorado, Pennsylvania,
Kentucky, Arkansas and other places. Almost all of the instances involved
white male (5) attacking other whites in a middle class or upper class
setting usually steeped in Christianity. They usually feel disenfranchised
and or vengeful and usually report some sort of great psychic pain. These
shootings are usually committed by teenagers, but among the first mass
murders was the Texas Tower incident in the 60's in which a white male
student killed from high atop the University of Texas Administration Building.
Family violence is another whole kettle of
fish. What about corporal punishment? What about spouses cursing, shoving
and even hitting each other ? What about parent bruising, twisting and
breaking parts of their own children ? What about a parent's hurtful name
calling words, like slut, worm, pig, good for nothing
Do we have to hurt people ? Do we have to
hurt those we love ? Oh the power of having those hurts done to us when
we were little - those behaviors can just tumble out so easily as we become
adults. One hurt usually leads to another hurt and nothing good results.
Are our children really ours to do with as we wish much as property or
punching bags ? Some people who resort to suicide think so and take their
children with them at the end.
On a broader level, we must reduce the violence
in cartoons, movies, television, news shows, entertainment shows, our own
language, in our politics, in our religion and in our homes. We need to
not unduly stress ourselves economically, governmentally and in our families.
To become angry is to be human - but it should not lead to violence - talk
about feelings, express yourself calmly, listen, negotiate.
Can we do anything about violence? Maybe we
can minister to victims of violence like the Kosovars and Russians. Maybe
we can minister to victims of violence with the Salvation Army, ot the
YWCA for instance. Maybe we can attempt to influence the political process
away from bomb throwing aggressive rhetoric and posturing with stupid,
hurtful resolutions to paying attention to quality of life, public safety,
transportation, and positive growth issues.
Maybe we can write letters to the editors,
write op-ed pieces. Speak out assertively but with a sense of humor when
any one is gratuitously attacked.
Certainly, we can band together, hand in hand
in unity to support and nurture each other, warts and all, modeling for
our young people that you do not have to hurt others to get ahead, that
if you mess up you can confess, apologize, make restitution, ask for forgiveness
and move on - for, if given a choice between Freud's death and life instincts,
I choose life.
James E. Stark, Ph.D.
Georgia Psychological Society
jestarkphd@aol.com